Nostalgia is not a Strategy
The last few years at this time of year I have headed to Glasgow for the Celtic Connections music festival, and I have blogged about the trip for the last couple. This is a shorter trip than usual but to keep me out of trouble and, hopefully, to entertain you in these darkest days of the year, I plan to knock out a few blogs.
These are the darkest days of the year. Indeed, of many a year. As I sit in my Standard Premium Avanti seat, surrounded by other passengers also on laptops despite there not being an under 50 in sight – ban social media for the over 60’s I say, it is bad for our mental health – the view out of the window is unremittingly grey. Is that just the weather or is it through the filter of my mood and the moment?
I tend not to write overtly political blogs. Most of you, my dear readers, will know my politics and anyway, they are pretty obvious from my discussion of historical sites, museums and galleries. I confess I am prone to the odd rant about the orangeshitgibbon, that monstrous weeping carbuncle leaking hate filled pus across our daily newsfeeds but that’s just commonsense. However, before I actually arrive in Glasgow today’s blog will take me into the realms of the bollocks sometimes called geopolitics. This piece headed by a quote from Mark Carney’s speech at Davos. I thought it an interesting expression and one worth considering in the political context as well as a more personal one.
In the context of his discourse, he was suggesting that nostalgia, by which he meant a clinging on to hope for a return to the ‘rules-based world order’, is no longer a strategy for ‘middle powers’. His premise being that the Orangespunkbubble has terminated any semblance of reliance on ‘rules-based institutions’ (e.g. UN, WTO, ICJ etc) and consequently he calls for these ‘middle powers’ to work together (rather than build individual indefensible ‘fortresses’) as a strategy for collective protection against the ‘major powers’. This seems to be a sensible, pragmatic response to the dire collapse of global decency in favour of hegemony and bullying. Carney, to be fair, came across in a statesmanlike manner, in contrast to most of the west’s weasel politicians, desperately failing to hide their panic – particularly the UK’s government. Whether the reality of his domestic policy is as impressive as his international profile I would be interested to know from my Canadian mates.
However, I am not sure everyone would be quite as nostalgic for the halcyon days of the ‘rules-based order’ as his audience, the Davos elite. These ‘rules’ did not seem to do a great deal for the Ukrainians or the Palestinians. An adherence to ‘rules’ does not deter UAE from supporting massacres in Sudan, the Saudis from bombing Yemen or Rwanda from funding rebel groups in Eastern Congo. Nor does it stop the western powers including the UK supplying the arms to those regional, US endorsed, bullies. Those same ‘rules’ were easily manipulated by the US when it came to sanctions that destroyed Iran’s economy or invasions of Iraq (twice) and Afghanistan. Between 1950 and today the list of smaller states being harassed, bullied, invaded by stronger signatories to ‘rules-based institutions’ is almost endless. (By the way, is it not ironic that Denmark sent troops in support of US action in Afghanistan? Just saying.) It is also of note that in the early 1950’s the UK’s then Labour government deliberately stalled ratifying the charters that set up these same institutions because they had some dodgy dirty work to finish off in Palestine, Malaysia and Kenya. These new rules were inconveniently restrictive for an ex-superpower, uncomfortably clinging on to a collapsing empire.
So, if it is not everyone who will be feeling nostalgic who will be, and for what? There are certainly very many politicians who are actually nostalgic for a time before the end of WWII when most of these institutions were set up to prevent another conflict of such global proportions. The rise in populist nationalism across the world but particularly in Europe/The West shares a vocabulary of ‘tradition’, ‘traditional values’, ‘national identity’, ‘taking back control’ and ‘Law and Order’. Always in a sense that those are the values that have been ‘lost’ since the good old days and all in very masculine, often misogynist, terms. This longing has its apogee in the extreme MAGA devotees. For these groups nostalgia IS a strategy. Trump and his acolytes hark back to a time when ‘might was right’ and have created a mythical way of life before ‘wokism’. These ‘good old days’ are indeterminate enough to defy scrutiny but certainly happened before the time that Carney is nostalgic for. Those ‘good old days were a time when stronger nations did not have to pretend to adhere to a ‘rules-based order’ just as strong white men did not have to pretend they did not have the power to subordinate black and brown people, women and anyone they deemed inferior. Many currently designated ‘middle-powers’ were then run by white male elites, powerful enough in their own right to be bullies in their own playgrounds. Nowadays, globalisation has created the largest playground of them all and only the US, China and possibly Russia are big enough to bully anyone without fear of retribution.
This unmasking of naked power at the national level reflects the desire of the populist right to return to the same freedom to dominate and intimidate at the domestic level. This now facilitated by the new bullying phenomena of big-tech. It is no coincidence that so many of these tech (and other) billionaires support and fund the politics of nationalism at both the international and domestic levels because the belief that the strong should not be restricted by the weak allows them to frow and maintain a dominant position (the ‘rules-based’ regulatory systems long being dismantled).
Of course, none of this is new. Carney’s call for ‘middle powers’ to join together and forge pragmatic alliances rather than to fall into a fortress mentality is in itself a strategy used across the centuries. Greek city states put their differences aside to stand against the Persian Empire just as middle European kingdoms stood together to make a bulwark against the westward march of the Mongols and then the Ottomans. States that built seemingly impregnable fortresses, eventually were forced by the overwhelming might of their local conquering empire, (be they Romans, Persians, Mongols, Mughals, the list is a long one) to make a choice; resist and face destruction or acquiesce and be absorbed into the victorious conquerors’ way of life. The same is true today of smaller states fending off a dominant power – the potential future of Greenland? – as well as the corporate world. Look how start-up technology firms whose idea attracts the gaze of one of the tech giants are forced to sell, become absorbed sell or be squeezed into oblivion.
So, Mark Carney is correct in a sense. Nostalgia is not a strategy. In fact, it was never really an option because there was nothing truthfully to be nostalgic for. Perhaps there was a short window, perhaps the twenty years after WWII, when it was possible for the so called ‘middle-powers’ to pretend or pay lip service to the idea that the big boys – powerful states and corporations – were bound by a set of rules but if it was ever true it was undone by the Reagan/Thatcher axis and since then by every further failure to stand up to the US state and corporate hegemony.
At this point (right now I am editing in the bar of my hotel) the scenic views of the northern lake district and the Scottish borders gradually gave way to a suburban landscape and then to Glasgow’s dull urban sprawl. Within a couple of hours, I was back in my comfort zone of a pint of Guinness in the Horseshoe Bar watching Glasgow eyebrows darken as Celtic threw away a two-goal lead to draw with Bologna. My nostalgia can take a more mundane interpretation as I catch up with some friends, sup a few beers and take in a couple of gigs. My blogging will revert to its more usual content. Yet there is a connection (apart from the Celtic one). My trips and subsequent blogs all follow some form of historical pattern – from the museums I visit to the ancient watering holes I drink in but a fascination with history is not the same as nostalgia. I fear our current crop of politicians are either ignorant of history or arrogant enough to ignore it. Was there ever a time when those in power had a historical perspective, the ability to learn from their predecessors’ and ancestors’ mistakes? I doubt it but if there was, then that would be a time to be nostalgic for.
The header picture is the cemetery by Glasgow Cathedral; ‘The Necropolis’ ,from last year’s trip up. It seemed appropriate.


As always – an extremely insightful dialogue into the mess eminating from across the pond.
Enjoy Glasgow, gigs and meeting old friends.
Perchance a haggis supper tomorrow with a whiskey or two?
thats the plan mate LOL
Excellent blog, thanks Keith. Hope you have a great time 😊
Ummm…hope the music is good 😄
Are you passing Sheffield on the way home?
have to get back for a book club event, reading my book. speak soon.
Excellent, I enjoyed your point of view on geopolitical interests and their relationship with history v’s nostalgia and leadership or the lack there of. Enjoy the festival and all that goes with it.
e se gon my bros
Enjoy your haggis tonight, Keef, as we will be doing in Worthing. P.s. I’m still happy to advise on the use of the hyphen, if you ever come round to its importance 🤣
Cheers
thanks Oga Patapata, agreeing with you, you had been quiet for a while so good you have come back online, no Wahala
Thanks Keith. Your insights are as worrying as they are impressive. Alan Little on the BBC News website has written this piece which entirely endorses your view. Perhaps he reads your blog?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c99kkerr93ko
I hope your stay in wonderful Glasgow raises your spirits and we see you soon.
Good rant!